Tuesday, September 22, 2009

Alma

It wasn't until Saturday evening that we ate at Alma on Columbia Street - I've been meaning to for a long time: just drinks and some appetizers, as we were having a real dinner at home, which was just as well.

The view is a killer, semi-industrial one of Manhattan and Jersey across the harbour - but the guacamole at this Mexican restaurant was bland, made with under ripe avocadoes, under- seasoned, no hint of lime or lemon, or even salt and...well. A waste. What more to say.

The ceviche was a collection of shrimp and scallops in a sweetish tomato soup that tasted like the kind of canned cocktail sauce that comes with those skating rink-sized platters of shrimp served in certain establishments and on game night. I'm told.

I'm dying for a simple ceviche where the fish is very fresh and made even better by citrus juice, take your pick; a herb, take your pick; and simple seasoning or a spice, take your pick.

I wouldn't go back to eat the real food, which is sad, as it's a great rooftop and so many reviews were good. But if the basics are treated with this carelessness, why would the main dishes be any different? I liked my margarita, with cucumber, and Vince's beer tasted just like beer.

Which was quite reassuring.

Tonight I'm making guacamole. With slow-cooked pig.

6 comments:

Sigrid said...

Funny, I never knew there was pig in guacamole...

Paula said...

Can't wait for dinner recollection. The ceviche idea sounds wonderful-simple ingredients to highlight fresh seafood. My mouth is watering. Wow, your site is like food & garden porno.

quiltcat said...

my ceviche=sea scallops, lime juice, red onion, cilantro, cayenne pepper...yes!! that place sounds quite disappointing but the view was certainly spectacular.

new york city garden said...

Apparently there's pig in bullets!

http://www.ediblegeography.com/pig-futures/

I can't say this for sure, but your first bad review?

Marie said...

Sigrid harharhar :-)

Paula - dinner postponed. No ripe avocadoes!!!

Paula - thank you. That's what I'm sayin'.

Frank, great pig link. My friend, I am a critical person. My blog is so one-sided and rose-tinted. My dilemma is, what is the point (actually, that really IS My Dilemma)...but about bad reviews, I mean. Who cares? Yackyackyack. The dead pork (sorry, bulleted pig)ribs I ate at Pete's Ale house a few weeks ago still rankle. You've never eaten such dishonest food...

new york city garden said...

Alma always intrigued, but I never stepped in. Now I won't. But you did get me to Lil Frankies, Stinky, and probably another place or two. Trust your judgement.
Keep it up;)